Current:Home > NewsTradeEdge Exchange:Opinion: After Kirby Smart suffers under Alabama fist again, the Georgia coach seems to expect it -AssetBase
TradeEdge Exchange:Opinion: After Kirby Smart suffers under Alabama fist again, the Georgia coach seems to expect it
Robert Brown View
Date:2025-04-10 02:43:35
- After Kirby Smart's latest loss to Alabama,TradeEdge Exchange the Georgia football coach gave a shocking quote.
- Nick Saban retirement came at right time for Alabama. Kalen DeBoer has got this covered.
- Colorado's Travis Hunter worthy of Heisman hype, but he faces uphill climb to award.
Alabama knocked Georgia's machine off the tracks and sent Kirby Smart's visor spinning askew in September's signature game. Kalen DeBoer, by taming Georgia in his first SEC game, showed that a seat on the "College GameDay" set is the best place for Nick Saban at this stage of his career.
Jalen Milroe catapulted to the top of the Heisman Trophy race, but Colorado's Travis Hunter and Boise State's Ashton Jeanty offer voters something to chew on if they're willing to consider candidates who don't play quarterback.
Here's what's lingering on my brain after Week 5:
Does Kirby Smart fear the bogeyman, Alabama?
Smart's poor visor. It spun every which way while he worked the sideline in Tuscaloosa. Alabama gave his Bulldogs fits like few have.
I don't know whether Smart fears Alabama, but his team looked shellshocked throughout the first half inside Bryant-Denny Stadium's roaring confines. The Bulldogs played soft and displayed shoddy fundamentals until mounting a mad-dash rally throughout the fourth quarter and nearly stealing the victory.
Curiously, Smart doesn’t seem all that concerned about his 1-6 all-time record against Alabama.
“What's everybody else's record against them, you know?” Smart said. “Has anybody got one better than 1-6 that’s played them (that many times)? I don't think so.”
True, few opponents beat the Tide, but Smart built Georgia to be unlike most other teams. And, in fact, Michigan, Texas, LSU and Tennessee defeated Alabama more recently than Georgia.
Smart remains an ace recruiter. He’s an effective motivator. So, why doesn't his team muster better performances against Alabama?
Most opponents can’t go toe-to-toe with Alabama when it comes to talent. Georgia can, but the Bulldogs have repeatedly looked overwhelmed by the moment of facing Alabama.
Smart never mastered Saban. Now, DeBoer outwitted him, and Smart seems to have come to expect living under Alabama's thumb.
CALM DOWN:Georgia is playoff trouble leads Week 5 overreactions
NEW FOCUS:Alabama wants shot at Texas after handling Georgia
Did Nick Saban retirement come at the right time for Alabama?
Yes, it absolutely did. The GOAT is where he should be – on the “College GameDay” set. Saban’s dominance at Alabama might never be duplicated, but he lost his stranglehold on the sport after NIL and the transfer wave altered the landscape, gave players more freedom and power, and stripped Saban’s omnipotence.
Plus, if Saban had waited a few years to retire, Alabama might have missed out on DeBoer, who's become a fitting heir to Saban’s scepter. This job isn’t too big for DeBoer. More, he’s breathing confidence into Milroe, who’s become a complete quarterback.
Saban earned the right to retire on his timeline, and he just so happened to pick a great moment for Alabama to change the guard.
Is Deion Sanders coaching the Heisman Trophy favorite in Travis Hunter?
No. Hunter, Colorado’s two-way star, builds a case for being the nation's most talented player. Incredibly, he's amassed 46 receptions to go with two interceptions. He grabbed this Heisman voter’s attention by striking the Heisman pose following his spectacular interception during Colorado’s win at Central Florida.
But, winning the award while not playing quarterback remains an uphill battle, especially if Alabama's Milroe keeps lighting up defenses. Sportsbooks favor Milroe for good reason. Elite quarterbacks from a playoff-contending team enjoy a head-start in the Heisman race.
In the past 24 years, only four non-quarterbacks won the Heisman.
Hunter will receive extra spotlight thanks to the Coach Prime effect. That helps his chances, but he’s not scheduled to face an opponent ranked in the top 15. That limits his opportunity for a so-called “Heisman moment” that voters crave.
Milroe provided more than a few of those moments while Alabama defrocked Georgia in a primetime game.
Voters rarely think outside the box for this award, so although Hunter enjoys a strong chance of being a Heisman finalist, winning the award would be an uncommon twist.
Will the SEC or Big Ten have more College Football Playoff qualifiers?
Right now, I project each conference with four qualifiers.
Ole Miss losing to Kentucky stings the SEC, which already endured body blows in Week 1 when potential contenders LSU lost to Southern California and Texas A&M fell to Notre Dame.
Alabama, Texas, Tennessee and Georgia are the SEC’s best chances for a playoff quartet. Missouri would emerge as the conference’s top option for a fifth qualifier if it wins Saturday at Texas A&M.
The Big Ten has done well to avoid a scenario like Ole Miss suffered, where a top playoff contender falls to a mid-tier conference foe.
Ohio State, Oregon and Penn State enjoy catbird positioning for the playoff. Several others from the league are in the mix, including Southern California, and … Indiana and Rutgers?! Yep, Indiana and Rutgers are undefeated. The Scarlet Knights also avoid Ohio State, Oregon, Penn State and Michigan. What a gift.
After Tennessee’s revolt of 2017 spoiled Greg Schiano getting the Vols’ job, he’s back where he works best, making Rutgers punch above its weight.
Blake Toppmeyer is the USA TODAY Network's national college football columnist. Email him at [email protected] and follow him on Twitter @btoppmeyer.
Subscribe to read all of his columns.
veryGood! (5921)
Related
- The White House is cracking down on overdraft fees
- Everything You Need To Enter & Thrive In Your Journaling Era
- Walmart's TV Deals Up To 47% Off Are Worth Shopping On The Big Screen
- Police: Philadelphia officer shot after scuffle with person in store; 2nd officer kills suspect
- Are Instagram, Facebook and WhatsApp down? Meta says most issues resolved after outages
- With the World Stumbling Past 1.5 Degrees of Warming, Scientists Warn Climate Shocks Could Trigger Unrest and Authoritarian Backlash
- Trump's lawyer questioned one of E. Jean Carroll's books during his trial. Copies are now selling for thousands.
- Fake George Carlin comedy special purportedly made with AI prompts lawsuit from his estate
- Are Instagram, Facebook and WhatsApp down? Meta says most issues resolved after outages
- Hurry, Lululemon Added Hundreds of Items to Their We Made Too Much Section, From $39 Leggings to $29 Tees
Ranking
- Kylie Jenner Shows Off Sweet Notes From Nieces Dream Kardashian & Chicago West
- A Publicly-Owned Landfill in Alabama Caught Fire and Smoldered for 50 Days. Nearby Residents Were Left in the Dark
- WWE PPV schedule 2024: When, where every premium live event will be this year
- After LA police raid home of Black Lives Matter attorney, a judge orders photographs destroyed
- NFL Week 15 picks straight up and against spread: Bills, Lions put No. 1 seed hopes on line
- Remembering the horrors of Auschwitz, German chancellor warns of antisemitism, threats to democracy
- Environmental officials working to clean up fuel after fiery tanker truck crash in Ohio
- Hold on to Your Bows! The Disney x Kate Spade Minnie Mouse Collection Is on Sale for up to 60% Off
Recommendation
Costco membership growth 'robust,' even amid fee increase: What to know about earnings release
Haley faces uphill battle as South Carolina Republicans rally behind Trump
Chicago Bears hire Eric Washington as defensive coordinator
JoJo Siwa will replace Nigel Lythgoe as a judge on 'So You Think You Can Dance'
Finally, good retirement news! Southwest pilots' plan is a bright spot, experts say
Alyssa Milano sparks criticism after seeking donations to son's baseball team
Why Crystal Hefner Is Changing Her Last Name
‘Saltburn’ actor Barry Keoghan named Hasty Pudding’s Man of the Year